Skip to main content

Ethics at the Forefront: Navigating the Path at frontier of Artificial General Intelligence

While we may want to cautiously avoid the term Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) today, it is evident from the general capabilities of the systems currently in place that we are either close to, or perhaps already have, some form of AGI in operation. In this scenario, it is crucial that AI ethics take center stage for several compelling reasons:

Unprecedented Autonomy and Decision-Making: AGI’s capability to autonomously perform any intellectual task necessitates ethical guidelines to ensure that the decisions made do not harm individuals or society.

Societal Impact and Responsibility: The profound impact of AGI across all societal sectors demands an alignment with human values and ethics to responsibly navigate changes and mitigate potential disruptions.

Avoiding Bias and Ensuring Fairness: To counteract the perpetuation of biases and ensure fairness, AGI requires a robust ethical framework to identify, address, and prevent discriminatory outcomes.

Control and Safety: The potential for AGI to surpass human intelligence necessitates stringent ethical guidelines and safety measures to ensure human control and to prevent misuse or unintended behaviors.

Transparency and Accountability: Given the complexity of AGI decision-making, ethical standards must enforce transparency and accountability, enabling effective monitoring and management by human operators.

Long-term Existential Risks: Aligning AGI with human values is crucial to avert existential risks and ensure that its development and deployment do not adversely impact humanity’s future.

Global Collaboration and Regulation: The global nature of AGI development necessitates international cooperation, with ethical considerations driving dialogue and harmonized regulations for responsible AGI deployment worldwide.

To expand on the important aspect of “Unprecedented Autonomy and Decision-Making,” the profound ability of AGI systems to perform tasks across various domains without human intervention is noteworthy. Organizations can proactively establish certain measures to ensure that the development and deployment of AI systems are aligned with ethical standards and societal values. Here’s what organizations can put in place now:

Aspect Manifestation Importance of Ethics
Decision-Making in Complex Scenarios Future AGI can make decisions in complex, unstructured environments such as medicine, law, and finance. Ensuring Beneficence: Ethical guidelines are needed to ensure decisions made by AGI prioritize human well-being and do not cause harm.
Continuous Learning and Adaptation Unlike narrow AI, AGI can learn from new data and adapt its behavior, leading to evolving decision-making patterns. Maintaining Predictability : Ethical frameworks can guide the development of AGI to ensure its behavior remains predictable and aligned with human intentions.
Autonomy in Execution AGI systems can act without human oversight, executing tasks based on their programming and learned experiences. Safeguarding Control: Ethics ensure that even in autonomous operation, AGI systems remain under human oversight and control to prevent unintended consequences.
Interaction with Unstructured Data AGI can interpret and act upon unstructured data (text, images, etc.), making decisions based on a wide array of inputs. Preventing Bias: Ethical standards are crucial to ensure that AGI systems do not perpetuate or amplify biases present in the data they learn from.
Complex Communication Abilities AGI can potentially understand and generate natural language, enabling it to communicate based on complex dialogues and texts. Ensuring Transparency: Ethics demand that AGI communication remains transparent and understandable to humans to facilitate trust and accountability.
Long-Term Strategic Planning AGI could plan and execute long-term strategies with far-reaching impacts, considering a wide array of variables and potential future scenarios. Aligning with Human Values: Ethical guidelines are essential to ensure that AGI’s long-term planning and strategies are aligned with human values and ethics.

By taking these steps, organizations can play a pivotal role in steering the development of AGI towards a future where it aligns with ethical standards and societal values, ensuring its benefits are maximized while minimizing potential risks.

 

Insights into AI Landscape – A Preface

AI Landscape and Key Areas of Interest

The AI landscape encompasses several crucial domains, and it’s imperative for any organization aiming to participate in this transformative movement to grasp these aspects. Our objective is to offer our insights and perspective into each of these critical domains through a series of articles on this platform.

We will explore key topics each area depicted in the diagram below.

1.      Standards, Framework, Assurance: We will address the upcoming International Standards and Frameworks, as well as those currently in effect. Significant efforts in this area are being undertaken by international organizations like ISO, IEEE, BSI, DIN, and others to establish order by defining these standards. This also encompasses Assurance frameworks, Ethics frameworks, and the necessary checks and balances for the development of AI solutions. It’s important to note that many of these frameworks are still in development and are being complemented by Regulations and Laws. Certain frameworks related to Cybersecurity and Privacy Regulations (e.g., GDPR) are expected to become de facto reference points. More details will be provided in the forthcoming comprehensive write-up in Series 1.

2.      Legislations, Laws, Regulations: Virtually all countries have recognized the implications and impact of AI on both professional and personal behavior, prompting many to work on establishing fundamental but essential legislations to safeguard human interests. This initiative began a couple of years ago and has gained significant momentum, especially with the introduction of Generative AI tools and platforms. Europe is taking the lead in implementing legislation ahead of many other nations, and countries like the USA, Canada, China, India, and others are also actively engaged in this area. We will delve deeper into this topic in Series 2.

3.      AI Platforms & Tools: AI Platforms and Tools: An array of AI platforms and tools is available, spanning various domains, including Content Creation, Software Development, Language Translation, Healthcare, Finance, Gaming, Design/Arts, and more. Generative AI tools encompass applications such as ChatGpt, Copilot, Dall-E2, Scribe, Jasper, etc. Additionally, AI chatbots like Chatgpt, Google Bard, Microsoft AI Bing, Jasper Chat, and ChatSpot, among others, are part of this landscape. This section will provide insights into key platforms and tools, including open-source options that cater to the needs of users.

4.      Social Impact:  AI Ethics begins at the strategic planning and design of AI systems. Various frameworks are currently under discussion due to their far-reaching societal consequences, leading to extensive debates on this subject. Furthermore, it has a significant influence on the jobs of the future, particularly in terms of regional outcomes, the types of jobs that will emerge, and those that will be enhanced or automated. The frameworks, standards, and legislations mentioned earlier strongly emphasize this dimension and are under close scrutiny. Most importantly, it is intriguing to observe the global adoption of AI solutions and whether societies worldwide embrace them or remain cautious. This section aims to shed light on this perspective.

5.      Others: Use Cases and Considerations:  In this Section, we will explore several use cases and success stories of AI implementation across various domains. We will also highlight obstacles in the adoption of AI, encompassing factors such as the pace of adoption, the integration of AI with existing legacy systems, and the trade-offs between new solutions and their associated costs and benefits.  We have already published a recent paper on this subject, and we plan to share more insights as the series continues to unfold.

The Executive Order!

Close on the heels of the formation of the Frontier Model Forum and a White House announcement that it had secured “voluntary commitments” from seven leading A.I companies to self-regulate the risks posed by artificial intelligence, President Joe Biden, yesterday issued an executive order regulating the development and ensuring safe and secure deployment of artificial intelligence models . The underlying principles of the order can be summarized in the picture.

The key aspects of the order focus on what is termed “dual-use foundation models” – models that are trained on broad data, uses self-supervision, and can be applied in a variety of contexts. Typically the generative AI models like GPT fall into this category, although, the order is aimed at the next generation of models beyond GPT-4.

Let’s look at what are the key aspects of what the order says in this part. Whilst the order talks about the

Safe & Secure AI

  • The need for safe and secure AI through thorough testing – even sharing test results with the government for critical systems that can impact national security, economy, public health and safety
  • Build guidelines to conduct AI red-teaming tests that involves assessing and managing the safety, security, and trustworthiness of AI models
  • The need to establish provenance of AI generated content
  • Ensure that compute & data are not in the hands of few colluding companies and ensuring that new businesses can thrive [This is probably the biggest “I don’t trust you” statement back to Big Tech!]

AI Education / Upskilling

  • Given its criticality, the need for investments in AI related education, training, R&D and protection of IP.
  • Support for programs to provide Americans with the skills they need for the age of AI and attract the world’s AI talent, via investments in AI-related education, training, development, research, and capacity and IP development
  • Encouraging AI skills import into the US [probably the one that most Indian STEM students who hope to study and work in the US will find a reason to cheer]

Protection Of Rights

  • Ensuring the protection of civil rights, protection against bias & discrimination, rights of consumers (users)
  • Lastly, also the growth of governmental capacity to regulate, govern and support for responsible AI.

Development of guidelines & standards

  • Building up on the Blueprint AI Bill of Rights & the AI Risk Management Framework, to create guidance and benchmarks for evaluating and auditing AI capabilities, particularly in areas where AI could cause harm, such as cybersecurity and biosecurity

Protecting US Interests

  • The regulations also propose that companies developing or intending to develop potential dual-use foundation models to report to the Govt on an ongoing basis their activities w.r.t training & assurance on the models and the the results of any red-team testing conducted
  • IaaS providers report on the security of their infrastructure and the usage of compute (large enough to train these dual use foundation models), as well as its usage by foreign actors who train large AI models which could be used for malafide purposes

Securing Critical Infrastructure

  • With respect to critical infrastructure, the order directs that under the Secretary Homeland Security, an AI Safety & Security Board is established, composed of AI experts from various sectors, to provide advice and recommendations to improve security, resilience, and incident response related to AI usage in critical infrastructure
  • All critical infrastructure is assessed for potential risks (vulnerabilities to critical failures, physical attacks, and cyberattacks) associated with the use of AI in critical infrastructure.
  • An assessment to be undertaken of the risks of AI misuse in developing threats in key areas like CBRN (chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear) & bio sciences

Data Privacy

  • One section of the document deals with mitigating privacy risks associated with AI, including an assessment and standards on the collection and use of information about individuals.
  • It also wants to ensure that the collection, use, and retention of data ensures that privacy and confidentiality are respected
  • Also calls for Congress to pass Data Privacy legislation

Federal Government Use of AI

  • The order encourages the use of AI, particularly generative AI, with safeguards in place and appropriate training, across federal agencies, except for national security systems.
  • It also calls for an interagency council to be established to coordinate AI development and use.

Finally, the key element – keeping America’s leadership in AI strong – by driving efforts to expand engagements with international allies and establish international frameworks for managing AI risks and benefits as well as driving an AI research agenda.

In subsequent posts, we will look at reactions, and what it means for Big Tech and for the Indian IT industry which is heavily tied to the US!